Ali vs Hogan Part 2: Governor Hogan Files a Motion to Dismiss

Previous Post in this series:

Next Posts in this series:

On Monday January 9th 2019, I filed a lawsuit against Maryland's Governor Larry Hogan for violating my civil rights by preventing me from getting a state contract because of my boycott of Israel and Israel's illegal settlements in the West Bank.

Today, Governor Hogan responded with a Motion to Dismiss my case. You can read his motion by clicking below.

The main arguments that Hogan makes in this motion are as follows:

  1. I lack standing to sue because the executive order applies to business entities, not individuals like me.
  2. I lack standing to sue because I have not submitted or been denied a bid or proposal.
  3. I lack standing because I have not voluntarily self-censored my pro-BDS advocacy.
  4. Neither Governor Hogan nor Attorney General Frosh are the proper parties to sue in this case because they don't have a "special relationship" to the enforcement of the executive order.
  5. Restricting boycotts does not violate the First Amendment. And NAACP vs. Claiborne does not control in this case.

Be the first to comment

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.

Freedom2Boycott defends the 1st Amendment right to boycott, including the boycott of Israel known as BDS. Click to help! Find an Event


get updates